The Trial of Your Faith

Over the years I’ve come across a similar story from many who have left the LDS Church, and it goes something like this:

I really wanted to know if the Church was true, if the Book of Mormon was true, and if Joseph Smith was a true prophet. I went to church, studied the Book of Mormon, and prayed asking to know, and I never got an answer. 

In a few instances I’ve been able to engage these people in discussion and I’ve asked “What if you didn’t pray long enough? What if God was waiting to see if you’d go for five years without an answer before he’d give you one, and you only went four?”

Almost universally my question has caused offense and defensiveness. I suspect the reason why is because those who leave the Church do so as a matter of faith, that is, they hope for something that is “not seen” or which they do not have absolute knowledge of, namely they hope the Church is not true. If they still hoped the Church were true would they not stay active in it, or at least not be opposed to it?

What surprises me is how quickly people give up. If I express this sentiment we get into a debate over what a “long time” is, as though there is an objective measure for such a thing. The attitude seems to be one of “Of course if God were real and the Church were true then I would get an answer after four years of praying about it. How could God could expect me to go longer than that?”

But the Book of Mormon, and bear in mind we’re speaking of those who profess to have believed the Book of Mormon at one point in time, teaches “that faith is things which are hoped for and not seen; wherefore, dispute not because ye see not, for ye receive no witness until after the trial of your faith.” (Ether 12:6)

What is this trial of our faith? Evidently it is some measure by which we are tested, prior to receiving confirmation of our faith, or evidence from God that what we have believed in, without hard evidence, is true. Who can judge whether we have passed the trial or not? It would seem perhaps only God can. And now the pertinent question, how long might it take for one to pass this trial? There would seem to be no answer, although it would seem that time is not the dominant factor, although it might be a contributing one. Simply put–when one passes the trial, then God will give them the evidence they need, which may or may not be exactly the evidence they desire. Is there any reason to believe this couldn’t take one’s entire life, and the evidence they desire might only be revealed to them after they pass from this life to the next? What about 10 years, 20, 50, or 80?

Yes, it can seem unfair when a 4-year old child gets up in a testimony meeting and states “I know the Church is true…” and here you are, a 25-year old sitting there not being able to say such a thing. I can see how that would lead a 25-year old to say “If I don’t know after all these years and with my intellectual abilities, there’s no way a 4-year old can know,” and then come to the conclusion that the 4-year old must not know, and that it’s all a sham. But this seems to me to be a short-sighted and prideful response, rather than one based on logic, reason, and humility. Perhaps the 4-year old has passed a trial of faith you haven’t, or perhaps the bar is set lower for that 4-year old than it is for you because that 4-year old has different needs than you have. Perhaps you were given missions in life that require that your faith be tested more thoroughly, or in different ways than other people. Perhaps you are being prepared for something and your trials are a necessary part of your training. If you want the Church to be true, then you will persevere. If you do not want the Church to be true, then you will find a reason to leave it.

Have a different take on things? Let me know.


  1. there is nothing about the lds church that is true.,.its a sex cult..evan todaye prophet is acused of trying to rape a lady from lehi utah when he was a bishop..they want to control your life and take your money and molest your mother sent my to stay with a exbishop to teach me how to play baseball and he raped me every day when i was 12 years old but my father did it before that but she weouldnt believe me

  2. Oh man….. Josh, based on this line of thinking, how do you know there isn't some other true religion out there that God is just waiting for you to find. What if your trial of faith is that your stuck in the wrong one and still need to discover that the one true religion is some small sect in Tibet that you've never heard of. Even if it takes you decades for you to find it. The above logic is giving the religion of your birth the ultimate benefit of the doubt. It also still assumes that historical or universal truths can be discovered by feelings and that the lack of those positive feelings leads people to believe it isn't true. I'll admit, it certainly didn't help that nothing remotely resembling a communication from heaven ever showed up. It's absence didn't make the church not true. It just made the promises in the scriptures kind of hollow. And it made God kind of a cruel character, but that's another discussion.

    What makes the church not what it claims to be is that the evidence is stacked so strongly against it that no discussion of feelings can play any legitimate part in the equation anymore. If the examination and weighting of the evidence was a football game the score would be 547 – 2. No matter how badly I wanted my team to win or "hoped" they would, it doesn't change the score. It really sucked that my team lost. And I was REALLY pulling for them.

  3. Church culture pretty much requires people to say they know. If we want to change people's dismay that they don't know, we have to change the expectation they've been raised with that they should know, should know it all right away, that investigators can pray, know, be baptized in two weeks, etc, etc. This obsession with being certain is damaging, I think. People aren't "allowed" by church culture to get up and say, in so many words, I don't really know, but I'm living as though it's good and right. That's not considered an acceptable testimony. That person's offering of a life lived in accordance with the gospel, but without any sure knowledge, is somehow second-class to the life lived "without a shadow of doubt."

  4. Usually when I would see a 4 year old giving his testimony his parent-s would be behind him whispering what he should say, I never seen a child give his testimony by himself. People who are born into Mormonism are brain washed even before there're able to speak.

  5. Sometimes, the answer is no, or we have to make up an answer. Sometimes, you just gotta go, “Well, that’s not workin.”

    It’s hard to believe it will always be all right because it won’t.

    I don’t even think about passing the trial, mainly because I am just too busy fumbling with it.

    I know some of my guardians are prolly like, “And, what’s happening NOW?”

    Even though I cannot understand why everyone must suffer so besides the generic answers, I know God lives. I may not understand His plans, but I do love Him. He’s said no to healing me for nine years now. Sometimes, it’s just life.

    I find myself afraid to ask, afraid to hope, but hope….that is all you can do–pray, move forward, and figure it out.

    I still believe God loves His children, even tho so mant people feel abandoned.

    We all have gifts. The question is…how we will use them to accept what God would like us to do?

  6. When I first read the book of Mormon the answer I got was so powerful and came to me so easily that I thought if I could share the book of Mormon with people that they would be converted just by reading it. Of course I found out it doesn’t work this way. Some people receive an immediate answer is I did and some people have to work very hard over years to get an answer and some people never get an answer.
    I have spent years trying to understand and reconcile this. In the church we are taught that everyone has been given the light of Christ. I believe that if you’re not following the light of Christ in your life you will not receive an answer. That is what is meant by real intent. If you ask to know if the book of Mormon is true but you do not have every intent to change your life because of it you will not receive an answer. Spiritual witnesses are reserved for the faithful only.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <s> <strike> <strong>